Financial advisor roleplay: a DIY investor who doubts advisor fees
Robert manages his own portfolio and thinks advisor fees are a waste. A friend suggested he talk to you. Earn his trust and book a no-obligation review, with no pressure and no promises about returns.
The buyer
Robert
54-year-old engineer who manages his own investments
- The situation
- A mutual friend, one of your clients, passed on your number and Robert agreed to a short introductory call. He has invested on his own for twenty years and plans to retire in about eight years.
- Personality
- Intelligent, skeptical and well read. Enjoys a debate. Respects people who admit what they don't know.
Hidden concern (for whoever plays the buyer)
He's confident picking investments but has no plan for drawing an income in retirement, or for his wife's finances if he dies first. It keeps him up at night.
Fictional training scenario. Names, companies and products are invented for practice.
Your goal
Book a no-obligation review meeting by showing curiosity about his goals, not by criticizing his investing.
Success looks like
- You didn't criticize his investment choices
- You asked about retirement goals and the household, not just the portfolio
- You uncovered the retirement income and spouse planning concern
- Robert agreed to a dated, no-obligation review
The opening line
"Look, I'll be upfront. I've managed my own money for twenty years and I don't see why I'd pay someone a percentage to do it."
Robert, 54-year-old engineer who manages his own investments
How a strong start sounds
An illustrative script for the first exchange. Say it in your own words; the point is the shape of the reply, not the exact lines.
- Robert
Look, I'll be upfront. I've managed my own money for twenty years and I don't see why I'd pay someone a percentage to do it.
- You
That's a fair position, and if you're happy with how it's going, you may not need me. Can I ask a different question? When you picture the first year after you stop working, how clear is the plan for turning the portfolio into income?
- Robert
Less clear than the investing part, I'll admit.
- You
That's the part a lot of people find hardest. Would it be worth an hour, with no obligation, to map it out and see if there's anything you'd want help with?
Curveballs to expect
Robert won't make it easy. Be ready for these.
- "What's your fee? And why is it worth it?"
- "My returns have been better than most advisors."
- "Can you guarantee you'd do better than me?"
- "I'll think about it and call you if I need you."
Scorecard
What a reviewer, or your own replay, should listen for. The criteria lean on Sandler Selling System.
| Criterion | What good looks like |
|---|---|
| Respecting his expertise | Acknowledges his experience genuinely and doesn't argue about his returns. |
| Broadening the conversation | Asks about retirement timing, income needs and his family, beyond picking investments. |
| Uncovering the real worry | Finds the gap around retirement income and his wife's finances through open questions. |
| Compliant language | Never promises or implies returns, and answers the fee question transparently. |
| Low-pressure next step | Offers a no-obligation review with a clear agenda and books a date. |
Want to score real calls the same way? Use the free sales call scorecard template.
To run this exact persona, rebuild it in the scenario builder (Starter plan and up), or run it with a colleague.
This is a fictional training scenario for practicing conversation skills. It is not financial advice. On real calls, follow your licensing, compliance and disclosure obligations.
Questions about this scenario
Why shouldn't I challenge Robert's investment returns?
Because arguing about returns puts him on the defensive, and it isn't where his real concern lies. Curiosity about his goals opens the conversation; debating his choices closes it.
Can I promise better returns to win the meeting?
No. Promising returns misleads clients and conflicts with advisor compliance rules. The scenario treats it as a fail.
Is this financial advice?
No. Robert and his situation are fictional. The scenario is for practicing how you run the conversation.
Objections in this scenario
Scripts and methods
More scenarios to practice
- DiscoveryB2B SaaSDifficulty: Medium
Discovery call with a guarded VP of operations
Priya, VP of operations at a 400-person regional logistics companyGoal: Uncover two problems with measurable impact and book a follow-up meeting that includes her boss, the COO.Open scenario - DiscoveryInsuranceDifficulty: Medium
Life insurance needs analysis with a new parent
Jess, 32-year-old new parent who requested an online quoteGoal: Complete a needs analysis, recommend an appropriate level of cover and handle 'I need to think about it' with a clear next step.Open scenario - DiscoveryRetailDifficulty: Easy
Retail floor: the "just looking" shopper
Ben, shopper browsing laptops in an electronics storeGoal: Open a conversation, find the need, recommend one laptop and offer one add-on that genuinely fits.Open scenario
Run it until it feels easy
Practice conversations like this one against an AI buyer and get every attempt scored. 250 free credits, no card.